Skip to main content

Book Review: Romantic Outlaws by Charlotte Gordon

http://charlottegordonbooks.com
Romantic Outlaws: The Extraordinary Lives of 
Mary Wollstonecraft and Her Daughter Mary Shelley

Excellent. Recommended reading for the New Year!

This very well-researched biography alternates chapters between the lives of Mary Wollstonecraft and her daughter Mary Shelley focusing on the women's writing lives, readings, study, politics, and influences as well as their relationships.

Mary Wollstonecraft was "a teacher, a hellfire preacher, a satirist, and a utopian dreamer," originator of the political philosophy of feminism, and the author of Vindication of the Rights of Women (1792). 

Mary Shelley was author of Frankenstein (1818), companion and editor to Romantic poets Percy Bysshe Shelley (her husband) and Lord Byron, and she expressed many of the same ideas as her mother in fiction.

Both women wrote about the importance of women's rights, independence and education — and faced scorn and criticism in society both for their words and for acting in accordance with their values. They both believed in Romanticism, "the elevation of emotion over reason, passion over logic, spontaneity over restraint, and originality over tradition." They believed that feminine values were needed in the world and that, "when men are guided by ambition, not love, and by fame, not family, then women and children pay the price." And they believed that art, words and ideas could be revolutionary and change the world for the better.

The biography is rich in detail, which could frustrate a casual reader, but may fascinate and fulfill anyone interested in these writers. When the author includes descriptions like "...almond trees bloomed in drifts of startling pink; delicate anemones and primroses brightened the gardens." it seems suitable to Mary Shelley's Romantic tendencies and rings true that the writer may well have observed and noted the flora and fauna around her in detail. When the author describes how Mary Wollstonecraft hated dragging her skirts through the mud "...the hem of her long dress dragging through the drifts, her ankles and feet icy cold. She wrote Godwin, 'You have no petticoats to dangle in the snow. Poor women, how they are beset with plagues—within and without.'" it helps the reader see the world more clearly through her experience and lens of time.

The book illuminates these fascinating women, the writers and philosophers of their times and the future writers they inspired. It shows how they defied the cultural expectations and the politics of the times in which they lived to forward and live their ideals. The women provide role models for creating art in conservative times. "Their refusal to bow down, to subside and surrender, to be quiet and subservient, to apologize and hide, makes their lives as memorable as the words they left behind. They asserted their right to determine their own destinies, starting a revolution that has yet to end." 

Let them be for us as they have been for others "a lifeline between generations."

Their lives also provide lessons on the mutability of history. We must pay attention to, forward, think and write about what is important to us — what we wish to be remembered and wish would influence the future.

Read this for: anyone interested in feminism, social justice, struggling with sadness, writers

Pairs well with: Half the Sky: Turning Oppression into Opportunity for Women Worldwide by Nicholas D. Kristof and I Am Malala: The Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban by Malala Yousafzai

Adding to my to-read list: Letters from Sweden, Mary Wollstonecraft Falkner, Valperga, Mary Shelley's novels

Notable: Both women struggled with depression (Mary Wollstonecraft attempted suicide) — they coped by writing and being in nature. "I must love and admire with warmth, or I sink into sadness," Mary Wollstonecraft said. She explored these questions: "What role could Nature play in healing an individual's pain? How was civilization harming or helping the human spirit? Could the life of the imagination triumph over a life dedicated to material pleasures?"

Quotable:

"Some write of what was; others of what is...but I write of what will be." — Mary Wollstonecraft 

"She knew she was going against the tide, but she was driven by her need to expose class hatred, racism, and unabated prejudice." — on Mary Shelley

"Passion could be a driving force for reform in the world and should be revered." — Mary Wollstonecraft

"It is the future that holds promise. Reformation, not nostalgia, will save humanity." — Mary Wollstonecraft

In Falkner: "...Mary (Shelley) emphasizes the power of the heroine to save the male characters from their ambitions, preserving their lives and bringing them into the warmth of the family...Acting not as a warrior, but as an advocate for peace, Elizabeth creates a utopia based on the 'feminine' values of compassion, love, and family. Without the follies caused by male ambition, Mary implies, there would be no more war, no more children lost."

"The artist's job was to summon these ideals, to envision and embody them so others could be inspired. Only in this way could the human condition improve. To (Percy Bysshe) Shelley, a great work of art could overthrow tyranny just as decisively as an army could. In fact, more decisively, because a painting or a poem could change people's minds and souls, something brute force could never do."

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Thoughts on "Depression Hates a Moving Target": What I Mean by Relatable

Relatable — I used this word in my reviews of Depression Hates a Moving Target   by Nita Sweeney on Goodreads and Amazon . It's a nice word, but overused of late. So, it feels lazy. What do I mean? I connected with this book. It made me reflect more on my own first marathon experience. It made me want to put on my running shoes and head out the door again. In fact, I did. Now, typically, my mental health doesn't hinder my ability to do the stuff I want to do and my body flies under the radar. Still, I also felt goofy stepping out in my running gear a lot of the time. I didn't see myself as a "runner" or an athlete. And, I had no idea if I could run 13 miles let alone 26.2 when I started. More to the point, could I stay moving for the 4+ hours straight it would take to complete the marathon? To do the training mileage, I knew I'd have to run through streets and trails on my own and that made me nervous, too. Waves of grief wash us to strange shores. Whe...

What is Solarpunk? Good question, great answers from our community

What is solarpunk? My fellow Glass and Gardens: Solarpunk Summers authors Commando Jugendstil and Tales from The EV Studio put together this video for the Turin International Book Fair . It features editors and authors from the solarpunk community sharing their thoughts. Together we're imagining optimistic futures based on renewable energy. My soundbite was: "Solarpunk futures are — green spaces with clean water that are pedestrian, collective, feminist, creative communities. And they include non-human animals. " Mary "solarpunk" Shelley cat did a great job (at 6:15) helping from her rather ridiculous cat tree which she absolutely loves. And what better time to wear this solar-colored "Veganism is Feminism" tee from The Herbivore Clothing Company . Seriously. I'm holding a stack of solarpunk books: Glass and Gardens: Solarpunk Summers  edited by Sarena Ulibarri which includes my story "Watch Out, Red Crusher!".  Wings of R...

Springy story review: "State Change" by Ken Liu

Why it springs to mind:  You'll never look at an ice cube the same way again. Where read: In the 2014 Hugo award-winning Lightspeed Magazine , August. Length: 5,194 words Summary: A woman has an ice cube for a soul. Memorable: How the story invites us to think about the shape of our soul, how it (or our perception of it) influences us and how it changes. What ordinary every day object would your soul be? A silver spoon, a beech stick? A great party conversation starter, this. Quote:  “All life is an experiment." Notable:  The protagonist Rina is an avid reader (always a good choice). Pairs well with: T.S. Elliot, Edna St. Vincent Millay Origin:  The story was written in 24 hours based on a writing prompt. (See Author Spotlight: Ken Liu ) About the author: Ken Liu’s debut novel, The Grace of Kings , the first in a fantasy series The Dandelion Dynasty, is due out from Saga Press ( a new Simon & Schuster imprint ) in 2015.